The Impact of ‘Skeuomorphism’ on the Increasing Fatality Rates on U.S. Roads — Streetsblog USA

    The Deadly Skeuomorphism of Pickup Trucks: A Missed Opportunity for Safer Design

    When faced with the sight of a massive F-150 Lightning in a parking lot, one cannot help but be taken aback by its sheer size. Towering over smaller vehicles like the Subaru parked behind it, the Lightning’s front end looms large, reaching shoulder height and enclosing nothing. Where once there was an engine, there now lies a “frunk” or front trunk, offering 400 liters of empty space.

    This design, however, is far from practical or safe. It is a prime example of skeuomorphism, a design approach that imitates the appearance or functionality of outdated objects. In the case of the F-150 Lightning, the bulky front end harks back to traditional pickup truck designs, negating opportunities for improved safety and aerodynamics.

    Skeuomorphs may have their place in familiarizing users with new technologies, as exemplified by the original iPhone’s interface resembling physical objects. However, when it comes to innovative designs, they often impede progress. By clinging to the physical limitations of older devices, skeuomorphs prevent designers from fully exploiting the potential of new technologies.

    Take digital cameras, for instance. Their film predecessors dictated the design of the camera, with the film rolling mechanism shaping the ergonomics and usability. When the digital camera emerged, manufacturers like Nikon had the freedom to create more ergonomic and flexible designs, unencumbered by the constraints of film and light paths. Yet, instead of embracing this freedom, many cameras today still retain the bump where the pentaprism used to be and mimic the appearance of film cameras.

    The pickup truck, too, falls victim to skeuomorphism. Originally designed for heavy-duty work with minimal frills, pickup trucks were compact and utilitarian. In the 1950s and ’60s, models like the Ford Ranchero and Chevy El Camino blurred the line between coupés and trucks, combining comfort with utility. However, they leaned more towards the car end of the spectrum.

    In contrast, when Volkswagen developed a pickup truck based on their van design, they utilized the space between the rear-mounted engine and the high bed for additional storage. Volkswagen’s approach exemplifies a departure from skeuomorphic design, where engineering principles take precedence over aesthetic traditions.

    Sadly, the opportunity to revolutionize pickup truck design has been squandered. American pickup trucks, in particular, prioritize image over functionality. Front-end designs resembling behemoth trunks may appeal to the notion of power and masculinity but do little to enhance safety or aerodynamics. In Europe, trucks are designed to meet stricter safety standards, with lower front ends and improved visibility. It begs the question of why American manufacturers refuse to adopt such designs.

    The rise of electric vehicles presents an ideal opportunity to reimagine the pickup truck. Without the need for traditional internal combustion engines, designers could create smaller, safer, and more aerodynamic vehicles. Yet, they persist with dangerous skeuomorphic designs that prioritize toxic elements of American car culture, such as road fatalities and the perception of masculinity tied to vehicle size.

    Children are more visible in front of an Abrams battle tank than they are in front of a standard pickup truck. The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration reports around 400 deaths and 20,000 injuries each year due to poor visibility in front of vehicles. With electric vehicles, this issue could be mitigated. However, due to skeuomorphism, the Ford F-150 Lightning’s unnecessarily large front end remains untouched, hindering visibility, safety, and aerodynamics.

    Designing vehicles free from skeuomorphic constraints presents endless possibilities. Canoo, a company that prioritizes practicality and usability, has developed van and pickup truck models reminiscent of Volkswagen’s innovative approach. However, Canoo faces resistance, as critics argue that certain shapes are more appealing and fit the preconceived notions of what a vehicle should look like.

    In conclusion, the prevalence of skeuomorphic design in pickup trucks is a missed opportunity for improved safety and functionality. As we transition to an era of electric vehicles, we have a chance to embrace forward-thinking design that prioritizes ergonomics and sustainability. It is time to break free from the shackles of skeuomorphism and embrace innovation. Only then can we create vehicles that truly serve our needs and contribute to a safer, more sustainable future.

    Latest articles

    Related articles